Today in Canada's Political History: January 13, 1928, Rookie Tory leader R.B. Bennett’s leadership-style celebrated as he prepares to face Mackenzie King in Parliament

  • National Newswatch

With Parliament set to assemble on this date in 1928, editorial writers at various Canadian newspapers previewed the arrival in the Commons of newly-minted tory leader R.B. Bennett. He had been chosen his party’s champion at a convention in Winnipeg the previous fall.

One editorialist at an Ontario newspaper looked forward to what he/she expected would be Bennett’s firm leadership style as he and his party faced off against the ever-wily Prime Minister Mackenzie King and his Liberals.

“One thing may be taken for granted when Parliament convenes and the Conservative Party finds Itself for the first time under the leadership of Hon. R. B. Bennett, K.C.; and that is that there will be no ‘Board of Strategy’ or "Kitchen Cabinet’ in evidence, seeking to ‘help’ Mr. Bennett out.

The plain fact of the matter, unless we very much miss our guess, is that Mr. Bennett will be his own leader and that those members of the Old Guard who may seek to help him in the leading will find themselves, as the late Ex-President Grover Cleveland would say, relegated to a position of innocuous desuetude. To be sure, Mr. Bennett will undoubtedly be glad to listen to all advice and suggestions offered to him, whether from members of the former Kitchen Cabinet or the late Board of Strategy but that undoubtedly will be as far as it will go. When it comes to the final decision, the new leader will do the deciding, since he is his own man and has a mind of his own.

When one recalls the shocking blunders of the old Conservative Board of Strategy in the last session of Parliament there need be little occasion for surprise at Mr. Bennett's course. Just as a well-known politician once said, ‘The way to resolve is to resolve,’ so the way to lead is to lead.”

For good or ill, Bennett did indeed display this style of one-person leadership when he became Prime Minister two-years later.




Arthur Milnes is an accomplished public historian and award-winning journalist. He was research assistant on The Rt. Hon. Brian Mulroney’s best-selling Memoirs and also served as a speechwriter to then-Prime Minister Stephen Harper and as a Fellow of the Queen’s Centre for the Study of Democracy under the leadership of Tom Axworthy. A resident of Kingston, Ontario, Milnes serves as the in-house historian at the 175 year-old Frontenac Club Hotel.