• Opinion - Curated opinion articles on current affairs and Canadian politics.
  • Polls - Articles on data, insights, polling and research from across Canada.
  • News -
  • US Trade -
  • Trending
  • International -
  • Pods - Curated feed of podcast episodes on current affairs and politics from around the political spectrum.
  • Healthwatch
  • Climate -
  • Economy -
  • Defence -
  • Resources -
  • Indigenous -
  • AI + Tech -
  • Art's History -
  • Politician's Pen - Articles written by sitting and former Canadian politicians.
  • Newsletter - Subscribe to The Buzz, our weekly newsletter with Peter Mansbridge.
  • Advertise -
  • Red
  • BlueDark
  • Orange
  • Green
  • BlueLight
  • Purple
  • Pink
  • Lellow
  • GreyLight
  • Charcoal

Topics

The Buzz May 10th 2025: Carney Holds His Own in the Oval

Welcome to the weekend, and welcome to The Buzz.

March 16, 1961 was a Thursday, and it turned out to be a big day in Ottawa. At dinner, my father asked us if we wanted to go to the airport to help welcome home the prime minister, John Diefenbaker. The PM was returning from a Commonwealth conference where he had led the way in preventing South Africa from rejoining the organization after it had been tossed out because of its racist apartheid policy. Dief was already being hailed as a hero for his leadership, not just by his Conservatives but by all sides in the House of Commons. The family piled into our old Nash Rambler and headed for Uplands. The airport welcome, at least as I remember it, was not organized by anyone. It seemed to be a grassroots outpouring, dozens of cars lined along parts of the airport route; people cheering. We weren’t alone, there were other families who got out of their cars to wave and clap as the PM’s car went by. It was a special moment for Diefenbaker, one of his last as it turned out, as he would lose his majority the following year, and then lose government altogether the year after that. 

I was thinking of that moment in the international spotlight for a Canadian PM this week when Mark Carney had his sitting in the Oval Office with Donald Trump. Sure, he did look a bit nervous and maybe even a bit nerdy, but when it came to what mattered, he delivered. “Canada will never be for sale,” bounced off the walls of the Oval and left the President of the United States slumped over in his chair, muttering his firehose of lies about whatever came to his mind. Whether you voted Liberal or Conservative shouldn’t matter – Carney did what others in that room haven’t done, from Starmer to Zelensky – he spoke truth to power, which, on Canada, when given the chance, Starmer didn’t; without losing his cool on Ukraine, which Zelensky did. 

And perhaps almost as important, Carney knew when to keep his mouth shut --- of the more than half an hour encounter in the Oval, the Canadian PM, according to my math, spoke for about three minutes, allowing Trump to ramble and blunder his way through one misrepresentation after another with his nodding sycophants lined up on the couch beside him. I’m sorry, but it’s such a pathetic image and it’s good to see many opinion writers across the globe handing this as a win to Carney. And more than that, suggesting it was a model for how to handle Trump that others should emulate.

No airport welcomes this time, but then again, that Dief stuff was so sixties!


Okay, onward with some deeper analysis. 

Try this from Lisa van Dusen, editor and publisher of Policy:

‘Not for Sale’ vs. ‘Never say Never’: Mark Carney’s Clean Getaway

Of course, it’s going to take a lot more than an optics victory on chairs and couches for this to lead anywhere good for Canada. 

Carney and his government know that securing sovereignty and prosperity is the goal here, and the Oval Office was just a start. 

Don Lenihan charts a path to that goal in his latest weekly piece for National Newswatch:

The Carney Test: Putting Sovereignty and Prosperity Back Together

There are a lot of pressing problems on Carney’s desk: from the tariffs issue, to Alberta secession talk, to housing, immigration and defence.  

But there’s actually something else he has to deal with right away before he can really tackle any of those. He needs a cabinet. He needs it to be relatively small. And he needs it to look new and fresh, not the same old faces. That’s a lot easier to say than do. Here’s how the Globe’s Bill Curry handled it:

🔒 Who will be in Carney’s cabinet? Adding new faces while staying lean will be the Prime Minister’s challenge

Pity Pierre Poilievre.  

Literally hours after losing the election, losing his seat and possibly even losing his house, he flew almost to the other end of the country to plant his flag in a new riding. He picked one of the safest Conservative seats in Canada, where someone had convinced the just-elected incumbent to step down so his leader could find safe territory to relaunch his hold on the party.

Sounds simple, but not so fast, argues Dale Smith:

Get ready for conservative civil war

Now, if anyone had the right to gloat over Poilievre’s election night defeat, it might have been his predecessor, Erin O’Toole. 

It’s generally conceded that it was Poilievre who unsheathed the knife that eventually plunged into O’Toole’s back after his 2021 election defeat to Justin Trudeau. But if he’s gloating on the inside, he’s not on the outside. He’d stayed away from the cameras throughout the campaign, but he decided to come out and talk this week as he sat down with CTV’s Vassy Kapelos:

Poilievre didn’t adapt enough to Trump or Trudeau shakeups, needs to ‘make peace’ with premiers: O’Toole

There’s lots more on all this in our two YouTube shows from this week. You can find Chantal Hebert and Rob Russo with Good Talk right here. And you can find Bruce Anderson and Fred DeLorey with Smoke, Mirrors and The Truth right here. 

Here’s a good one. And from the Hollywood Reporter, no less.

Ever wondered how Donald Trump comes up with those “news from nowhere” ideas? The other day, he suddenly tweeted (or whatever you call sending texts from his own social media company) that he was going to reopen Alcatraz. Now, why and who or what inspired him to suggest it? Trust The Buzz to search through the possibilities:

Donald Trump Wants to Reopen Alcatraz — After Watching ‘Escape From Alcatraz’ on TV

If that’s true, and PBS gives ideas to Donald Trump, then maybe Pierre Poilievre should start watching CBC.

Usually, I ignore this next kind of story, which you can find on the cover of grocery store tabloids, but this one comes from one of my favourite websites, often quoted here in The Buzz. 

It’s studyfinds.org and keeps up with the latest research findings. Now, we all want to find the secret potion that will prolong life, right? Well, check this out:

‘Fountain Of Youth’ Protein Boosts Lifespan, Muscle, and Brain Power in Aging Mice — After Single Dose

That wraps up The Buzz for this week. We’ll be back in seven days.

The Buzz is a weekly publication from National Newswatch that shares insights and commentary on the week’s developments in politics, news and current affairs.

Subscribe to 'The Buzz' with Peter Mansbridge

Every Saturday, Peter Mansbridge provides thoughtful takes on this week's news stories. Subscribe for FREE! You can unsubscribe any time. 

Full Name
  • About -
  • Advertising + Sponsorship -
  • Newsletter -
  • Privacy & Terms of Use -
  • Sources -

© 2025 National Newswatch