Greg MacNeil

While National Newswatch does not keep an archive of external articles for longer than 6 months, we do keep all articles written by contributors who post directly to our site. Here you will find all of the contributed and linked external articles from Greg MacNeil.

Why would Gen Z fight for a country they can’t build a life in?

Why would Gen Z fight for a country they can’t build a life in?

Canada won’t be able to recruit a generation that can’t afford a future. The raise for Canadian Armed Forces members was necessary, but it won’t fix the real problem. Young Canadians aren’t choosing careers based on wages alone. They’re choosing based on whether a job gives them a future they can actually build, and right now the CAF doesn’t. Not...

Ottawa needs lobbyists

Ottawa needs lobbyists

Ottawa is a foreign country. People outside it need guides and translators. They don’t speak the same language, they don’t know their way around, geographically or politically. Even the vocabulary is foreign. Normal people don’t say things like “I need to crosswalk this MC,” “Do you have an agenda item for the MIN-DM (pronounced mindim)?” or “We need a four...

An accidental election?

An accidental election?

On December 13, 1979, Joe Clark’s government fell after failing to pass its budget. It wasn’t supposed to happen. Clark miscounted the votes, and Canadians found themselves in an accidental election.

The robots aren't the risk. The meetings are.

The robots aren't the risk. The meetings are.

Ottawa says it wants an AI revolution. But before the robots arrive, there’ll be meetings. Many, many meetings. Mark Carney’s government has declared that artificial intelligence will be the future of the federal public service. A government that’s smarter, faster, and more responsive to Canadians. Imagine services that anticipate your needs instead of losing your forms. It’s the kind of...

Canada’s new dollar-a-year man (and why he’s worth every penny)

Canada’s new dollar-a-year man (and why he’s worth every penny)

Defence lobbyists love a good Second World War analogy. You can’t get through a defence procurement conference without someone invoking the Battle of the Atlantic or the arsenal of democracy. So let’s lean right in. If Canada’s new Defence Investment Agency is a rerun of the 1940s, then Stephen Fuhr is our C.D. Howe and Doug Guzman is our dollar-a-year...

Carney's big bet

Carney's big bet

Canadians don’t need to be told the world’s getting harsher. They chose a serious Prime Minister for a reason, and for now there’s little appetite for populist politics. They want solutions. The problem for the Carney government is that the solutions to our biggest challenges often seem at odds with each other, and how he resolves that tension will define...

Building the Ark before the rain - Why Canada was right to rebuild warship capacity at home

Building the Ark before the rain - Why Canada was right to rebuild warship capacity at home

I’m a big fan of Dan Gardner’s work. A couple of years ago he wrote an essay called Preparing for the Next Big One, and it’s been rattling around in my head ever since. He describes what he calls the “tombstone mentality,” the cycle of complacency that drives how societies prepare for foreseeable disasters. It goes like this...

Everything everywhere all at once - Every Prime Minister has their defining first act.

Everything everywhere all at once - Every Prime Minister has their defining first act.

Jean Chrétien had program review. His government restructured the federal budget from the ground up, asking fundamental questions about what government should do and how. Stephen Harper had the Economic Action Plan, launched in response to the global financial crisis. Justin Trudeau’s first term was consumed by the renegotiation of NAFTA, a trade fight that tested the Canada–US relationship in...

The Best Thing That Ever Happened Was Losing

The Best Thing That Ever Happened Was Losing

Ottawa has been in a sprint since January. A new Prime Minister. A new cabinet. A new agenda. Now, the House has adjourned for the summer. The BBQ circuit begins. Vacations will be taken. And whether they admit it or not, many will use the time to catch their breath and reflect. They should. Because in politics, everyone wants to...

Canada's Not Flashy. That's the point.

Canada's Not Flashy. That's the point.

Benjamin Franklin once said that America is “a republic, if you can keep it.” I’m not American, but I’ve always admired that quote. It’s a warning and a challenge in one sentence. A reminder that a country’s values are only as strong as its citizens’ commitment to them. Next week, Canadians celebrate Canada Day. Over the last six months, many...

Most Governments Peak in Year One. Here’s Why.

Most Governments Peak in Year One. Here’s Why.

The Carney government has set some ambitious targets. Defence. Productivity. Housing. Trade diversification. Infrastructure. Projects of National Interest. All of it. Every problem, fixed. Every policy lever, pulled. Every chart, up and to the right. And look, good for them. I sincerely mean it. I love these ambitious goals. The truth is, you do not get into government to manage...

Keep it simple, stupid

Keep it simple, stupid

In politics, you can't say ten things and expect people to remember one. You have to say one thing ten times. Then say it ten more. That’s message discipline. Not because your audience is dim, but because they’re distracted. Ministers are distracted. Staff are distracted. Even you are probably distracted. Message discipline isn’t about dumbing things down. It’s about making...

Ottawa's New Gatekeeper Won't Take Meetings

Ottawa's New Gatekeeper Won't Take Meetings

Government relations has always been a human business. In Ottawa, nothing works quite the way people think it does. The org chart is a polite fiction. Power moves through invisible networks of overworked staffers, assistant deputy ministers, and policy advisors whose names you’ll never read in the paper. These are the so-called nobodies who actually run the country. That was...

The Five Percent Reckoning

The Five Percent Reckoning

Admiral Hyman Rickover, known as the father of the American nuclear navy, understood something that is true of most large systems: they rarely reward risk-takers. They tend to value process over outcomes. They remember mistakes, not initiative. And unless political leaders demand otherwise, the system rarely changes. In the 1950s, Rickover was handed a task no one had ever attempted...

Ottawa Runs on "Nobodies"

Ottawa Runs on "Nobodies"

One of the great enduring myths of Government Relations is that the person with the fanciest title makes the decision. Ministers are the final deciders. Deputy ministers execute. Policy Advisors analyze. The machine hums along in a perfect linear fashion. Sure. And the Leafs win the Cup every year. Anyone who has spent more than ten minutes in Ottawa knows...

We Need an Uncle Louis

We Need an Uncle Louis

The McKinley comparisons to Trump are no longer theoretical. They are baked into policy. Tariffs are rising. Protectionist industrial strategies are being rolled out. American trade is now openly transactional, backed by executive muscle and shaped by economic nationalism. This is the new normal for Canada’s closest friend and largest trading partner. This weekend, Canadians mark Victoria Day, a holiday...

Fewer Voices, Faster Decisions: Carney’s Inner Cabinet Reflects a Proven Model

Fewer Voices, Faster Decisions: Carney’s Inner Cabinet Reflects a Proven Model

“You cannot fight a war on a committee of twenty.” That was the United Kingdom’s Prime Minister Lloyd George’s blunt assessment in 1916. Faced with a divided and sluggish Cabinet during the First World War, he created a five-member War Cabinet to bypass bottlenecks and focus Britain’s war effort. It worked. And it helped win the war.

This Isn't Top Gun: Air Combat Is About Stealth, Not Swagger

This Isn't Top Gun: Air Combat Is About Stealth, Not Swagger

That exchange in Top Gun: Maverick wasn’t just a nod to Tom Cruise’s enduring appeal as fighter pilot. It was an admission from the screenwriters that modern air combat has moved on. Modern fifth-generation fighters like the F-35 are not built for close-range dogfights. They are designed to detect threats from long distances, strike first, and vanish before the enemy...

The End of the Peace Dividend. The Start of the Defence Dividend

The End of the Peace Dividend. The Start of the Defence Dividend

Across the Western world, a generational shift in defence and security policy is underway. The so-called “peace dividend” that followed the Cold War, when countries reduced military spending to invest in domestic priorities, is now history. In the words of UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, we now need to prepare for the defence dividend. This week, Starmer committed the United...

A 100-day plan for the next PM to hit Canada’s defence spending targets within one year

A 100-day plan for the next PM to hit Canada’s defence spending targets within one year

As the United States retreats from being a unipolar power, the prevailing global order is at a crossroads. For Canada, it’s time to start thinking about what comes next and what it means for Canadian policy. The Hub is running a new essay series to grapple with these seismic changes and offer a new clear-headed direction for Canadian foreign policy...

Defence and Dollars - New spark*insights research shows a path forward on defence spending

Defence and Dollars - New spark*insights research shows a path forward on defence spending

Canada buys military equipment ponderously and hesitantly. We’ve got lots of conditions. Rethinking and revisions. If we were shopping retail, the store owner would be tempted to ask us to leave. The reason for this approach is the deep seeded belief that the military only have one chance to get a procurement right. That there is no room for error...

Defence and Dollars - New spark*insights research shows a path forward on defence spending

Defence and Dollars - New spark*insights research shows a path forward on defence spending

Canada buys military equipment ponderously and hesitantly. We’ve got lots of conditions. Rethinking and revisions. If we were shopping retail, the store owner would be tempted to ask us to leave. The reason for this approach is the deep seeded belief that the military only have one chance to get a procurement right. That there is no room for error...

Speak Softly, and Carry a Big Stick

Just days before the assassination of President McKinley, Vice President Teddy Roosevelt stood before an eager crowd at the Minnesota State Fair. It was here that Roosevelt shared a vision of American foreign policy that would shape his country’s approach to international relations for more than a century. “Right here let me make as vigorous a plea as I know...

Making the Political Case for Increased Defence Spending in an Uncertain World

Making the Political Case for Increased Defence Spending in an Uncertain World

It’s 2025, three years into the Ukraine conflict. and Russia, emboldened by its military achievements, perhaps emboldened by a politically distracted NATO Alliance, targets Latvia, where Canadian troops are deployed. Concurrently, a Russian submarine in the Arctic launches attacks on critical North American infrastructure, effectively hindering our response capabilities. Swiftly, Russia achieves its objectives in Latvia. This scenario is not...